Should I…?
Fixed or variable?
A fixed rate against an ARM, a variable rate or a tracker: which costs less if rates rise, fall or hold, and how far rates would have to rise before fixed wins.
Updated
How long you'll keep the loan
ARM fixed for
0.00 points · Rates are where they are today when the ARM resets
Over 7 years, if rates are where they are today when the ARM resets
ARM saves $24,499
ARM stays cheaper over 7 years even if rates rise 5 points.
| Measure | Fixed rate | ARM |
|---|---|---|
| Rate today | 6.50% | 5.50% |
| Monthly payment now | $2,212 | $1,987 |
| Highest payment | $2,212 | $1,987 |
| Interest over 7 years | $152,285 | $127,786 |
| Still owed at the end | $316,457 | $310,856 |
If rates go another way
Rates fall 1 point
ARM saves $30,935
Rates stay put
ARM saves $24,499
Rates rise 1 point
ARM saves $18,040
Rates rise 2 points
ARM saves $11,562
The ARM keeps its starting rate for 5 years, then adjusts every six months within the usual caps: up to 2 points at the first change, 1 point after that, 5 points over the loan. Its starting rate here is today's 30-year average minus 1 point, about the gap lenders were quoting in November 2026; enter the quotes you get. Cost is the interest paid over 7 years.
A variable rate usually starts lower, so it wins if rates stay put or fall and loses if they rise far enough. On a $450,000 Canadian mortgage, a 3.70% variable rate saves about $16,354 of interest over a 5-year term against a 4.49% fixed if rates hold, but if rates rise 1 point, the fixed rate comes out $814 cheaper; the break-even is a rise of about 0.88 points.
How this calculator works
Enter the loan, the fixed rate and the variable rate you're offered: an adjustable-rate mortgage (ARM) in the US, a variable rate that follows prime in Canada, or a tracker that follows Bank Rate in the UK.
Choose where you think rates go. Variable rates move in quarter-point steps over the next two years and then hold; a US ARM keeps its starting rate for 5, 7 or 10 years and then adjusts within the usual caps (2 points at the first change, 1 point every six months after, 5 points over the loan).
Over the time that matters (how long you'll keep a US loan, a Canadian term or a UK deal), the tool adds up the interest each option costs, shows the payment month by month, and finds the rise in rates that would make the two cost the same.
A worked example
The same choice in each country, at example rates:
- Canada: $450,000, 4.49% fixed vs 3.70% variable, 5-year term, rates hold
- Variable saves $16,354
- Same, if variable rates rise 1 point
- Fixed saves $814
- US: $350,000, 7.25% fixed vs 6.25% 5/6 ARM, kept 7 years, rates hold
- The ARM saves $24,658
- Same, if rates are 2 points higher at the reset
- The ARM saves $11,572
- Same ARM, sold after 5 years (before it resets)
- The ARM saves $17,602
- UK: £200,000, 5.25% 2-year fix vs 4.90% tracker, rates hold
- The tracker saves £1,392
Example rates. Cost is the interest paid over the period; fees, penalties and what happens after the term or deal ends aren't included.
Who it's for
- Canadians choosing between a fixed and a variable term.
- US buyers weighing an ARM's lower starting rate against a 30-year fixed.
- UK borrowers deciding between a fixed deal and a tracker.
Frequently asked questions
Is a fixed or variable mortgage better?
Neither always. A variable rate usually starts lower, so it costs less if rates hold or fall, and more if they rise past the break-even. In the Canadian example that's a rise of about 0.88 points over the term; a fixed rate buys certainty about the payment.
When does an adjustable-rate mortgage (ARM) make sense?
When you're fairly sure you'll sell or refinance before it resets. A 5/6 ARM's rate can't change for five years, so if you move within that time you keep the lower rate the whole way. If you stay, the payment can jump at the reset, by up to 2 points of rate at the first change.
What happens to my payment if variable rates rise?
With a payment that follows the rate (US ARMs, UK trackers, some Canadian variables), it rises at each change. Many Canadian variable mortgages keep the payment fixed instead, so more of it goes to interest and the payoff stretches; if rates rise far enough you can hit a trigger rate and have to pay more.
Can I switch from variable to fixed later?
In Canada most lenders let you lock a variable mortgage into a fixed term at any time, at their rate on that day. Some UK trackers have no early repayment charges, so you can move to a fix. In the US you'd usually refinance, which has closing costs.