Should I…?

Lower rate or lower fees?

Points, an arrangement fee or cash back against a lower rate: which costs less over the time you'll keep it, and when the trade pays off.

Updated

How long you'll keep the loan

No points

% of the loan

With points

% of the loan

Over 7 years

With points saves $2,646

With points costs more at the start and pulls ahead after 48 months.

The two options compared over 7 years
MeasureNo pointsWith points
Rate6.50%6.25%
Monthly payment$2,212$2,155
Paid up front$0$3,500
Cost over 7 years$152,285$149,638
Still owed at the end$316,457$315,118
How far with points is ahead (above the line) or behind, month by month
Break-even: month 48+$2,646

One point is 1% of the loan and usually lowers the rate by about a quarter of a point; ask lenders for the exact trade. Points only pay off if you keep the loan past the break-even, without refinancing or selling. Cost is everything you pay plus what you still owe, minus the loan.

Paying more up front for a lower rate only pays off if you keep the loan long enough. One discount point ($3,500 on a $350,000 loan) for 6.5% instead of 6.75% breaks even after 48 months and saves about $2,659 over 7 years, but costs $865 more if you sell or refinance after 3.

How this calculator works

Enter two offers: the rate and what each costs up front. In the US that's discount points (1% of the loan each); in the UK, a deal's arrangement fee, which you can pay or add to the mortgage; in Canada, cash back paid to you at closing in exchange for a higher rate.

For the time you'll keep the loan or deal, the tool adds up everything each option costs: money up front, every monthly payment, and what you still owe at the end, minus the loan you needed. Cash back counts as money in; a fee added to the loan counts through the bigger balance.

It shows which option is cheaper, by how much, and the month the option that costs more at the start pulls ahead, with a chart of the running difference.