For homeowners
Should I break my mortgage?
The penalty for leaving early, against what a lower rate saves over the time you have left. Canada's IRD, UK early repayment charges and US prepayment penalties.
Updated
Most US mortgages have none. If yours does, it's in your note: at most 2% in years one and two, 1% in year three.
Over the 5 years you'll keep it
Switching saves about $8,027
The lower rate covers the fees after about 2 years 6 months.
- Prepayment penalty
- $0
- Fees to switch
- $8,000
- Interest saved
- $16,027
- Monthly payment
- $2,047
- from $2,253
Your loan estimate lists closing costs; points or lender credits change them. For a fuller comparison, try the refinance calculator.
Breaking a mortgage early pays when the interest you'd save before your term ends is more than the penalty and switching costs. A Canadian with $450,000 left at 5.5% fixed and 30 months to go would pay a $23,625 penalty (the interest rate differential) to move to 4.2%, and lose $10,986 by the end of the term.
How this calculator works
Canada: a fixed-rate penalty is the larger of three months' interest and the interest rate differential (IRD): your rate minus the lender's current rate for the time left, less the discount you were given off the posted rate, on the balance for the months left. Variable-rate penalties are usually three months' interest.
UK: early repayment charges are a percentage of the balance, often stepping down each year of the deal. Most lenders let you overpay 10% a year without a charge, so the tool can use that allowance first.
US: most mortgages have no prepayment penalty; if yours does, enter it as a percentage. The tool then compares the interest at your rate and the new rate over the time left, takes off the penalty and costs, and shows the month the saving covers them.
A worked example
Two owners thinking of switching to a lower rate before their term or deal ends:
- Canada: $450,000 at 5.5% fixed, 30 months left, to 4.2%
- $23,625 penalty
- Interest saved over the 30 months
- $14,139
- Net after the penalty and $1,500 of costs
- $10,986 behind
- UK: £200,000 at 5.2%, 2 years left, 3% charge, 10% overpaid first
- £5,400 charge
- Net after the charge and £1,000 of costs
- £3,207 behind
Example rates and penalty terms; your lender's own penalty statement is the figure that counts.
Who it's for
- Owners whose rate is well above today's rates.
- Anyone selling, refinancing or switching before their term or deal ends.
- Canadians who've been quoted an IRD and want to check it.
Frequently asked questions
How is a mortgage break penalty calculated in Canada?
For a fixed rate, it's the higher of three months' interest and the interest rate differential. Lenders that use posted rates take your original discount off the comparison rate, which can make the IRD much larger.
Is it worth paying an early repayment charge to remortgage?
Only if the interest saved before your deal would have ended is more than the charge plus fees. Using your 10% overpayment allowance first can shrink the charge.
Do US mortgages have prepayment penalties?
Most don't. Some loans have one in the first three years; it's shown on your loan estimate and closing disclosure.