Should I…?
Overpay or invest?
Put extra money on the mortgage, or invest it? What you'd have either way.
Updated
Invested in
No tax on the growth.
In 27 years, overpaying leaves you about
$20,993 ahead
Investing wins if it earns more than about 6.7% a year after tax. Overpaying “earns” your mortgage rate, guaranteed; investments can do better or worse.
OverpayComes out ahead
- Mortgage-free
- 7 years and 6 months sooner
- Interest saved
- $107,672
- Invested after it's paid off
- $256,574
Invest
- Mortgage-free
- in 27 years
- Paid in
- $97,200
- Investments at the end
- $235,581
- Your payment now
- $1,967/mo
- Breakeven return
- 6.7%
- after tax, a year
- Paid off in
- 19 years and 6 months
- if you overpay
Before either: keep an emergency fund and clear costlier debts like cards. An employer 401(k) match is free money and usually beats both. See the exact savings in the overpayment calculator.
Overpaying your mortgage earns your mortgage rate, guaranteed. Investing can earn more, but might not. On £200,000 at 4.5% with 22 years left, putting £250 a month into an ISA comes out ahead if it earns more than about 4.6% a year. This tool compares the two with your numbers.
How this calculator works
Both paths put the same extra amount aside each month until the date your mortgage would have ended anyway. Overpaying pays the mortgage off sooner, then invests the whole former payment. Investing leaves the mortgage alone and invests the extra each month.
The tool shows what each leaves you with and the yearly return investing must beat after tax. In a tax-free account (Roth IRA or 401(k), TFSA or RRSP, ISA or pension) the growth isn't taxed; in a taxable account we take about 20% of it.
It doesn't count US mortgage interest deductions or employer matches, which can tilt toward investing.
A worked example
A £200,000 mortgage at 4.5% with 22 years left, and £250 a month extra:
- Overpaying: mortgage-free sooner by
- 5 years and 8 months
- Overpaying: interest saved
- £32,824
- Investing at 6% a year: ahead by
- £16,788
- Investing at 3% a year: behind by
- £14,642
- Return investing must beat
- 4.6% a year
Example returns for illustration; investments can fall as well as rise.
Who it's for
- Homeowners with spare money each month.
- Anyone torn between being mortgage-free and investing.
- Savers with a fixed rate deciding where extra cash goes.
Frequently asked questions
Is overpaying my mortgage a good idea?
It's a guaranteed, tax-free return equal to your mortgage rate. Keep an emergency fund first, and clear costlier debts like cards.
What return do I need to beat?
Roughly your mortgage rate, after tax on the investment. The tool works out the exact figure for your numbers.
Can I do both?
Yes, and many people split the extra between the two.