Should I…?
Wait for 20% down?
Buy now and pay mortgage insurance, or keep renting and saving until you have 20%.
Updated
What we assume each year
After 10 years, buying now leaves you about
$6,532 better off
You'd reach 20% in 3 years and 4 months (around March 2030), when the home costs about $455,867. Rising prices and rent while you save cost more than the mortgage insurance.
Buy nowComes out ahead
- Down payment
- $40,000 (10%)
- Price
- $400,000
- Owning costs
- $3,584/mo
- Mortgage insurance
- $165/mo for 9 years and 1 month
Wait for 20%
- Down payment
- $91,530 (20%)
- Price
- $455,867
- Rent paid first
- $83,970
- Mortgage insurance
- None
- Time to 20%
- 3 years and 4 months
- Price rise meanwhile
- $55,867
- Home worth in 10 years
- $592,098
- at 4% a year
Both sides spend the same each month: rent plus savings. Whoever owns pays the mortgage, property tax, insurance, mortgage insurance and upkeep instead, and saves what's left. Closing costs are about the same either way, so they're left out. Prices and rates are guesses: try a few. See what the insurance itself costs in Mortgage insurance.
Waiting for 20% down saves mortgage insurance, but you pay rent and prices may rise while you save. For a $400,000 home in Texas with $40,000 saved and $1,200 a month going in, buying now comes out about $6,532 ahead after 10 years. This tool runs both paths with your numbers.
How this calculator works
Both paths spend the same each month: today's rent plus what you save. If you wait, you pay rent and save the rest until your savings reach 20% of the price, which keeps rising. If you buy now, you pay the mortgage, property tax, insurance, mortgage insurance and upkeep, and save whatever's left.
Ten years from now (or at least a year after the later purchase), the tool compares what each path leaves you with: the cash in the bank minus the mortgage still owed, on the same home. Closing costs are left out because they're about the same either way.
The answer depends on guesses about prices, rent and returns, so the tool lets you change them. When the gap is small, it says so instead of picking a winner.
A worked example
A $400,000 Texas home, $40,000 saved, $1,200 a month saved, $2,000 rent, a 6.5% example rate, prices rising 4% a year:
- Time to save 20%
- 3 years and 4 months
- Price by then
- $455,867
- PMI paid if you buy now
- $17,985
- Rent paid while waiting
- $83,970
- After 10 years
- Buying now comes out about $6,532 ahead
Guesses for illustration. Change prices, rent, savings returns and upkeep in the tool.
Who it's for
- Buyers with 5–15% saved, deciding whether to keep saving.
- Anyone told they must have 20% down before buying.
- People in fast-rising or flat markets testing both cases.
Frequently asked questions
Is it better to wait for 20% down?
Not always. Mortgage insurance can cost less than a year or two of rising prices and rent, but in a flat market with cheap rent, waiting can come out ahead. It depends on your numbers.
How does the tool decide who's better off?
It compares what each path leaves you with on the same date: savings minus the mortgage still owed. Both paths spend the same each month.
What if prices fall?
Then waiting gains. Set price growth to zero or below to see it.