Should I…?
Compare homes side by side
Two or three homes with the same down payment and rate, so you see what the homes themselves cost: each month and on the day you buy.
Updated
Years
The difference
Home 2 costs $368 more a month than Home 1
and needs $3,044 more cash to buy. Over five years the monthly gap adds up to $22,052.
A month
$3,138
- Principal & interest$2,190
- Property tax$539
- Home insurance$250
- Mortgage insurance (PMI)$159
- Cash to buy
- $48,574
- Down payment $38,500, buying costs $10,074
- Income to carry it
- $134,483 a year
A month
$3,505
- Principal & interest$2,332
- Property tax$574
- Home insurance$250
- Mortgage insurance (PMI)$169
- HOA$180
- Cash to buy
- $51,618
- Down payment $41,000, buying costs $10,618
- Income to carry it
- $142,520 a year
Same down payment, rate and term for every home, so only the homes differ. Taxes and insurance are typical figures for each state; the listing's own tax bill and fees are better if you have them.
The cheaper home isn't always cheaper each month: fees and tax can close much of the gap. In Ontario, at 10% down and a 4.5% example rate, a $700,000 townhouse with a $260 fee costs $211 more a month than a $620,000 condo with a $520 fee, though the price gap is $80,000.
How this calculator works
Every home gets the same down payment, rate and term, so the only differences are the homes themselves: the price, where they are (property tax, insurance and transfer tax depend on the state, province or nation) and their monthly fees (HOA, condo or strata fees, or a UK service charge).
For each home you see the monthly cost split into the mortgage, property tax (Council Tax in the UK), insurance, mortgage insurance and fees, then the cash to buy: down payment plus closing costs, including land transfer tax or stamp duty where it applies, and the income it needs on lenders' usual ratios.
The cheapest home each month is marked, and the gap is spelled out, including what it adds up to over five years. The comparison can be shared as a link and is kept in My home plan, in your browser only.
A worked example
Two Ontario homes, 10% down, 4.5% example rate, 25 years, first-time buyer:
- Condo, $620,000, $520 fee
- $4,284 a month
- Townhouse, $700,000, $260 fee
- $4,495 a month
- Difference each month
- $211
- More cash to buy the townhouse
- $9,600
- Land transfer tax, condo / townhouse
- $4,875 / $6,475
Example rate for illustration; the tool starts at today's average rate. Includes the CMHC premium added to the loan and Ontario's first-time buyer land transfer tax refund.
Who it's for
- Buyers choosing between two or three listings.
- Anyone weighing a condo with fees against a house without them.
- People comparing the same price in two places with different taxes.
Frequently asked questions
How do I compare two houses for affordability?
Use the same down payment, rate and term for both, then compare the full monthly cost (mortgage, tax, insurance and fees), the cash to buy and the income each one needs. The price alone hides fees and tax.
Do condo or HOA fees affect how much I can borrow?
Yes. In Canada lenders count half of condo fees in your GDS and TDS ratios; in the US, HOA dues count in your debt-to-income ratio. Higher fees lower the price you qualify for.
Why does the same price cost more in another place?
Property tax, insurance and transfer taxes differ by state, province and nation, sometimes by thousands of dollars a year.